Civil Law

Initiated on Wednesday, June 22nd, 2022, in Anchorage, Alaska

The purpose of this page is to share my civil law case regarding my property in Anchorage, Alaska and any observations about the nature of Civil Law, strategy, and deficiencies in the process.

Contents

Civil Trial - Friends of the Stewart Public Trail v. Pugh & Mattanaw

Docket, Events

*Source: Anchorage Courtview: https://records.courts.alaska.gov/

10/14/2019 02:30 PM Courtroom 403, Nesbett Courthouse Status Hearing: Superior Court Hearing Held Gandbhir, Una
01/13/2020 03:00 PM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Trial Date Setting Conference Hearing Reset Crosby, Dani R
01/15/2020 10:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Trial Date Setting Conference Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
02/11/2020 03:30 PM Courtroom 403, Nesbett Courthouse Status Hearing: Superior Court Hearing Vacated Gandbhir, Una
04/09/2020 02:30 PM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Motion Hearing Hearing Vacated Crosby, Dani R
06/08/2020 03:00 PM Courtroom 403, Nesbett Courthouse Trial Call: Superior Court Civil Hearing Vacated Gandbhir, Una
06/22/2020 08:30 AM Courtroom 403, Nesbett Courthouse Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Vacated Gandbhir, Una
08/06/2020 03:30 PM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Motion Hearing Taken Under Advisement Crosby, Dani R
10/05/2020 08:30 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Vacated Crosby, Dani R
11/05/2020 03:00 PM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Oral Argument Hearing Reset Crosby, Dani R
12/10/2020 03:00 PM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Oral Argument Taken Under Advisement Crosby, Dani R
06/21/2021 03:00 PM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Trial Call: Superior Court Civil Hearing Reset Crosby, Dani R
07/19/2021 08:30 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Reset Crosby, Dani R
12/13/2021 03:30 PM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Trial Call: Superior Court Civil Hearing Continued Crosby, Dani R
01/06/2022 02:30 PM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Trial Call: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
01/14/2022 11:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Status Hearing: Superior Court Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
01/18/2022 08:30 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Reset Crosby, Dani R
01/18/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
01/20/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
01/21/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
01/24/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
01/25/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
01/26/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
01/27/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
01/28/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Reset Crosby, Dani R
01/28/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
02/01/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Reset Crosby, Dani R
02/01/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
02/02/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
02/03/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
02/04/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Reset Crosby, Dani R
02/04/2022 10:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
02/07/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Vacated Crosby, Dani R
02/08/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Held Crosby, Dani R
02/09/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Reset Crosby, Dani R
02/28/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Hearing Reset Crosby, Dani R
03/02/2022 09:00 AM Courtroom 304, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial: Superior Court Civil Taken Under Advisement Crosby, Dani R

Docket, Filings

*Source: Anchorage Courtview: https://records.courts.alaska.gov/

03/18/2019 Initial Judicial Assignment: Honorable Gregory Miller
03/18/2019 Complaint for Quiet Title Receipt: 1614004 Date: 03/18/2019
03/18/2019 Summons and Notice to Both Parties of Judicial Assignment
03/18/2019 Attorney Information Attorney Meacham, Thomas E representing Plaintiff Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc as of 03/18/2019
04/10/2019 First Amended Complaint to Quiet Title to Public Non-Motorized Easement by Prescription Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
04/10/2019 Plaintiff’s Notice of Filing First Amended Complaint to Quiet Title to Public Non-Motorized Easement by Prescription, [and Motion for Leave to Apply Earlier-Filed Index of Exhibits and Exhibits 1 Through 15 to First Amended Complaint] Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
04/10/2019 Plaintiff’s Notice of Service of Process and Returns of Service (Upon Franklin D. Pugh, Jr., and Oksana V. Pugh) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
04/10/2019 Motion for Leave to Apply Earlier-Filed Index of Exhibits and Exhibits 1 through 15 to First Amended Complaint [filed with Plaintiff’s Notice of Filing First Amended Complaint to Quiet Title to Public Non-Motarized Easement by Prescription] Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #1
04/11/2019 Entry of Appearance Attorney Fitzgerald, Kevin T representing Defendant Pugh Jr, Franklin D as of 04/11/2019 Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant);
04/11/2019 Entry of Appearance Attorney Fitzgerald, Kevin T representing Defendant Pugh, Oksana V as of 04/11/2019 Oksana V Pugh (Defendant);
04/19/2019 Copies Made per Admin Rule 9 (e)(1) For a single document or portion of a document $5 If copies of multiple documents are requested at the same time, for each additional document (after the first) $3 Receipt: 1623394 Date: 04/19/2019
04/24/2019 Demand for Jury Trial Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant);
04/24/2019 Answer to First Amended Complaint to Quiet Title to Public Non-Motorized Easement by Prescription Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant);
04/26/2019

Order Granting Leave to Apply Earlier-Filed Index of Exhibits and Exhibits 1 through 15 to First Amended Complaint

  Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc
Case Motion #1 Motion for Leave to Apply Earlier-Filed Index of Exhibits and Exhibits 1 through 15 to First Amended Complaint [filed with Plaintiff’s Notice of Filing First Amended Complaint to Quiet Title to Public Non-Motarized Easement by Prescription]
04/26/2019 Plaintiff’s Notice of Service of Process and Return of Service (Upon Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
04/29/2019 Entry of Appearance [re: extension to Answer] Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
04/30/2019

Notice of Deficient Filing(s) mailed re: The document(s) you submitted to the court is/are deficient. Please provide the following:

1 Your “Entry of Appearance” filed 4/29/19 lacks a motion and proposed order for your request to grant a 14 day extension to file an Answer, as required by Civil Rule 77. Please file this motion and proposed order.

1 Your “Entry of Appearance” filed 4/29/19 lacks a Proper Proof of Service as required by Civil Rule 5. All documents file with th court must be served on all other parties and a Certificate of Service must be filed with the court. Please serve and filed the Certificate.

1 Your “Entry of Appearance” filed 4/29/19 lacks contact information. Please file a “Notice of Change of Contact Information”, or include your contact information on your next filing.

This deficiency is not being [formally] served on Christopher Cavanaugh at this time as the court has no contact information submitted by this party. However, the court will use an email supplied by the Plaintiff, legal.net.cavanaugh@gmail.com, to forward this deficiency.

Deficiencies must be corrected within 20 calendar days from the date of this notice.

Notice of Deficient Filing (Anchorage) (10/18) Sent on: 04/30/2019 11:40:20.31 Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
05/01/2019 Entry of Appearance Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
05/01/2019 Notice of Change of Judge MILLER (Peremptory Challenge) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
05/01/2019 Peremptory Disqualification by Defendant/Respondent/// Assigned to JUDGE GANDBHIR
05/01/2019 Motion for Extension of Time to File Answer [05/15/19] Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Cavanaugh, Christopher Matthew Case Motion #2
05/03/2019 Plaintiff’s Motion to Hold Defendant Cavanaugh’s Notice of Change of Judge as Untimely Filed and to Rescind Change, and Memorandum in Support Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #3
05/03/2019 Plaintiff’s Non-Opposition to Defendant Cavanaugh’s Motion for Extension of Time to Answer Complaint Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #2: Motion for Extension of Time to File Answer [05/15/19]
05/09/2019 Cavanaugh’s Response to Peremptory Challenge of Superior Court Judge Gregory Miller Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #3: Plaintiff’s Motion to Hold Defendant Cavanaugh’s Notice of Change of Judge as Untimely Filed and to Rescind Change, and Memorandum in Support
05/15/2019 Order Denying Motion Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #3 Plaintiff’s Motion to Hold Defendant Cavanaugh’s Notice of Change of Judge as Untimely Filed and to Rescind Change, and Memorandum in Support
05/15/2019 Answer to First Amended Complaint to Quiet Title to Public Non-Motorized Easement by Prescription Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
05/15/2019

Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time to File Answer

  Cavanaugh, Christopher Matthew
Case Motion #2 Motion for Extension of Time to File Answer [05/15/19]
05/17/2019

Initial Civil Pretrial Order Issued (Anchorage)

Initial Pretrial Order (Anchorage) Sent on: 05/16/2019 11:12:33.68
05/28/2019 Plaintiff’s Motion for Extension of Time to Suggest Trial Dates and Length of Trial, and Memorandum in support [until 06/11/19] Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #4
06/11/2019 Parties’ Joint List of Three Trial Dates Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
06/13/2019

Order Granting Plaintiff’s Motion for Extension of Time

  Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc
Case Motion #4 Plaintiff’s Motion for Extension of Time to Suggest Trial Dates and Length of Trial, and Memorandum in support [until 06/11/19]
06/24/2019 Plaintiffs’ Inital Factual Disclosures Thomas E Meacham (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
07/08/2019 Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendants’ Initial Factual Disclosures, and Memorandum in Support Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #5
07/09/2019 Routine Pretrial Order Issued Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); ; Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr, Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Thomas E Meacham (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
07/11/2019 Defendants Franklin D Pugh Jr and Oksana V Pugh’s Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defenants’ Intial Factual Disclosures Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant) Case Motion #5: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendants’ Initial Factual Disclosures, and Memorandum in Support
07/22/2019 Plaintiff’s Reply in support of Motion to Compel Defendants’ Initial Factual Disclosures Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #5: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendants’ Initial Factual Disclosures, and Memorandum in Support
07/23/2019

Order Granting Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant’s Initial Factual Disclosures

  Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc
Case Motion #5 Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendants’ Initial Factual Disclosures, and Memorandum in Support
07/23/2019

Order Denying Motion to Compel as to Defendants Franklin & Oksana Pugh

  Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc
Case Motion #5 Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendants’ Initial Factual Disclosures, and Memorandum in Support
08/01/2019 Order Granting Defendant’s Motion for Extension of Time to Provide Initial Factual Disclosures Case Motion #5: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendants’ Initial Factual Disclosures, and Memorandum in Support
08/07/2019 Second Amended Complaint to Quiet Title to Public Non-Motorized Easement by Prescription—LODGED Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
08/07/2019 Plaintiff’s Response to Alternative Dispute Resolution Requirement of Inital Pretrial Order Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
08/07/2019 Plaintiff’s Motion for Leave to File Second Amended Complaint to Quiet Title to Public Non-Motorized Easement by Prescription, and Motion for Leave to Apply Earlier-Filed Index of Exhibits and Exhibits 1 Through 15 to Second Amended Complaint Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #6
08/15/2019 Non-Opposition to Second Amended Complaint Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Case Motion #6: Plaintiff’s Motion for Leave to File Second Amended Complaint to Quiet Title to Public Non-Motorized Easement by Prescription, and Motion for Leave to Apply Earlier-Filed Index of Exhibits and Exhibits 1 Through 15 to Second Amended Complaint
08/22/2019 Defendant’s Motion for Extension of Time to Provide Initial Factual Disclosures [Until 9/5/19] Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Cavanaugh, Christopher Matthew Case Motion #7
08/22/2019

Notice of Deficient Filing(s) mailed re:

The document(s) you submitted to the court is/are deficient. Please provide the following:

1 Proposed order for your Motion for Extension of Time to Provide Initial Factual Disclosure that was filed on 8/22/19 as required by Civil Rule 77.

1 Other: You are not permitted to file documents by fax with our court unless you have prior written consent from the judge assigned to your case. Civil Rule 5.1(a)(1).

1 Other: The filed document did not contain a signature or an original signature so you must sign the document and re-file. Civil Rule 11 and Civil Rule 76.

Deficiencies must be corrected within 20 calendar days from the date of this notice.

Notice of Deficient Filing (Anchorage) (10/18) Sent on: 08/22/2019 13:38:32.89 Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
08/23/2019 Answer to Second Amended Complaint to Quiet Title to Public Non-Motorized Easement by Prescription Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant);
08/26/2019 Defendant’s Motion for Extension of Time to Provide Initial Factual Disclosures and Request for Approval to File Documents Via Fax and/or Email Delivery Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #7: Defendant’s Motion for Extension of Time to Provide Initial Factual Disclosures [Until 9/5/19]
08/26/2019

Order Granting Plaintiff’s Motion for Leave to File Second Amended Complaint and Motion for Leave to Apply Earlier Filed Index of Exhibits and Exhibits 1 Through 15 to Second Amended Complaint

  Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc
Case Motion #6 Plaintiff’s Motion for Leave to File Second Amended Complaint to Quiet Title to Public Non-Motorized Easement by Prescription, and Motion for Leave to Apply Earlier-Filed Index of Exhibits and Exhibits 1 Through 15 to Second Amended Complaint
08/27/2019 Defendant’s Motion for extension of Time to Provide Initial Factual Disclosures and Request for Approval to File Documents via Fax and/or Email Delivery Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #7: Defendant’s Motion for Extension of Time to Provide Initial Factual Disclosures [Until 9/5/19]
08/28/2019 Plaintiff’s Motion, Memorandum and Affidavit Requesting an Order Compelling Defendant Cavanaugh to Respond to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production by a Date Certain Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #8
08/28/2019

Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time to Provide Initial Factual Disclosures

  Cavanaugh, Christopher Matthew
Case Motion #7 Defendant’s Motion for Extension of Time to Provide Initial Factual Disclosures [Until 9/5/19]
09/05/2019 Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh’s Initial Factual Disclosures Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
09/06/2019 Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh’s Initial Factual Disclosures Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
09/06/2019

Motion Deemed Moot / Mr. Cavanaugh has filed his initial disclosures on 09/05/2019

  Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc
Case Motion #8 Plaintiff’s Motion, Memorandum and Affidavit Requesting an Order Compelling Defendant Cavanaugh to Respond to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production by a Date Certain
09/26/2019 Reassertion of Plaintiff’s Motion Requesting an Order Compelling Defendant Cavanaugh to Respond to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production by a Date Certain Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #8: Plaintiff’s Motion, Memorandum and Affidavit Requesting an Order Compelling Defendant Cavanaugh to Respond to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production by a Date Certain
10/01/2019 Order Granting Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Response to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production Case Motion #8: Plaintiff’s Motion, Memorandum and Affidavit Requesting an Order Compelling Defendant Cavanaugh to Respond to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production by a Date Certain
10/08/2019 Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Award of Attorney Fees as Sanction Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh for Expenses of Compelling Discovery Response [filed with Affidavit & Proposed Order] Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #9
10/14/2019 Notice of Hearing / Status Hearing Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); ; Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr, Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Thomas E Meacham (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
10/14/2019 Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh’s Response to Plaintiff’s First Request for Production Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #8: Plaintiff’s Motion, Memorandum and Affidavit Requesting an Order Compelling Defendant Cavanaugh to Respond to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production by a Date Certain
10/14/2019 Plaintiff’s Notice of Completion of Service of Summons by Publication Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
10/14/2019 Plaintiff’s Notice [Motion] of Completion of Service of Summons by Publication (Alaska Civil Rule 4(e)(6)(B)) [filed with Proposed Order] Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #10
10/16/2019 Plaintiff’s Response to Court’s Request at Status Hearing of October 14, 2019 Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
10/23/2019 Defendant’s Motion for the Court to Vacate Its Order Granting Plaintiff’s Request to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh to Respond to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production by a Date Certain, and to Deny Plaintiff’s Request for Award of Attorney’s Fees as a Sanction Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #9: Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Award of Attorney Fees as Sanction Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh for Expenses of Compelling Discovery Response [filed with Affidavit & Proposed Order]
10/23/2019 Defendant’s Motion for the Court to Vacate its Order Granting Plaintiff’s Request to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh to Respond to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production by a Date Certain [filed with proposed Order] Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Cavanaugh, Christopher Matthew Case Motion #11
10/25/2019 Response to Plaintiff’s Second Amended Complaint Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
10/28/2019 Plaintiff’s Answer to “Counterclaim” Arguments of Defendant Cavanaugh Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
10/28/2019 (Plaintiff’s Reply in Support of Motion for Sanctions, and in) Opposition to Defendant Cavanaugh’s Motion to Vacate Earlier Court Order Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #11: Defendant’s Motion for the Court to Vacate its Order Granting Plaintiff’s Request to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh to Respond to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production by a Date Certain [filed with proposed Order]
10/28/2019 Plaintiff’s Reply in Support of Motion for Sanctions (and in Opposition to Defendant Cavanaugh’s Motion to Vacate Earlier Court Order) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #9: Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Award of Attorney Fees as Sanction Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh for Expenses of Compelling Discovery Response [filed with Affidavit & Proposed Order]
11/01/2019 Request for Reassignment by Judge
11/05/2019 Recusal by Judge
11/12/2019 Defendant’s Response in Opposition to Plaintiff’s 10/28 Reply in Support of Motion for Sanctions, and Opposition to Motion to Vacate Court Order Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #11: Defendant’s Motion for the Court to Vacate its Order Granting Plaintiff’s Request to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh to Respond to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production by a Date Certain [filed with proposed Order]
11/13/2019 Order Regarding Reassignment / 10 days for objection Reassignment to Superior Court Judge Dani Crosby held in Abeyance
11/19/2019 Plaintiff’s Response to Court’s Order Regarding Reassignment Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
11/21/2019 Motion of Leave of Absence from Court Proceedings [from 12/3/19 until 1/3/20] Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Cavanaugh, Christopher Matthew Case Motion #12
11/22/2019 Notice to Court RE Reassignment Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant);
11/26/2019 Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #13
11/27/2019 Order Granting Motion Case Motion #9 Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Award of Attorney Fees as Sanction Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh for Expenses of Compelling Discovery Response [filed with Affidavit & Proposed Order]
11/27/2019 Order Granting Motion Case Motion #10 Plaintiff’s Notice [Motion] of Completion of Service of Summons by Publication (Alaska Civil Rule 4(e)(6)(B)) [filed with Proposed Order]
11/27/2019 Order Denying Motion Case Motion #11 Defendant’s Motion for the Court to Vacate its Order Granting Plaintiff’s Request to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh to Respond to Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production by a Date Certain [filed with proposed Order]
11/27/2019 Order Granting Motion Case Motion #12 Motion of Leave of Absence from Court Proceedings [from 12/3/19 until 1/3/20]
12/02/2019 Calendaring Notice issued: Trial Setting Conference on January 13, 2020 at 3:00 pm before Judge Crosby, courtroom 304.
12/09/2019 Defendant Mattanaw’s Motion for Leave to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Cavanaugh, Christopher Matthew Case Motion #14
12/10/2019 Plaintiff’s Non-Opposition to Defendant Cavanaugh’s Motion for Extension of Time to Respond to Plaintiff’s Motion for Order to Show Cause (linked to motion #14) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #14: Defendant Mattanaw’s Motion for Leave to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
12/11/2019 Notice to Court About Contemporaneous Mailing of Already Faxed Motion for Leave to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production (linked to motion #14) Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #14: Defendant Mattanaw’s Motion for Leave to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
12/20/2019 Defendant Mattanaw’s Motion for Leave to Respond In Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Request for Production Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #13: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
12/20/2019 Notice to Court About Contemporaneous Mailing of Already Faxed Motion for Leave to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Request for Production Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #13: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
12/20/2019 Notice to Court About Contemporaneous Mailing of Already Faxed Motion for Leave to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Request for Production (linked to motion #14) Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #14: Defendant Mattanaw’s Motion for Leave to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
01/03/2020 Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #13: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
01/08/2020 Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #13: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
01/08/2020

Order Granting Mattanaw’s Motion for Leave to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production

Case Motion #13: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production, Case Motion #14: Defendant Mattanaw’s Motion for Leave to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
01/10/2020 Calendaring Notice issued: Trial Setting Conference on January 13, 2020 cancelled due to court conflict. Trial Setting Conference rescheduled to 1/15/2020 at 10:00 am before Judge Crosby, courtroom 304.
01/13/2020 Plaintiff’s Reply in Support of Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production (linked to motion #13) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #13: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
01/16/2020 Routine Pretrial Order Issued
01/17/2020 Order Granting Motion Case Motion #13 Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
01/22/2020 Plaintiff’s Notice of Clarification Regarding Case Motion #13: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
01/23/2020 Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #15
01/28/2020 CD/Tape Duplication Receipt: 1715185 Date: 01/28/2020
01/28/2020 Order Case Motion #13: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
02/03/2020 Mattanaw’s Response to Court Order 13 (Fax) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
02/03/2020 [CORRECTED] Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel (linked to motion #15) [filed w/corrected Affidavit] Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #15: Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel
02/03/2020 Notice of Plaintiff’s Lodging of Documents Correcting Name of Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #16
02/04/2020 Notice to Court Concerning Defendant Mattanaw’s Payment of Sanctions to Plaintiff (Original Filed 02/05/2020) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
02/04/2020 Response to Interrogatories II, for Interrogatories One Through Six Including Those Specifically Requested Regarding 1,2 and 4, In Plaintiff’s Notice for Clarification Regarding Case Motion #13 (Original Filed 02/05/2020) Case Motion #13: Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant Cavanaugh’s Substantive Responses to Certain Interrogatories and Requests for Production
02/04/2020 Response with Productions Five and Six as Ordered for Case Motion Thirteen (Filed Along with Red Thumb Drive) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #15: Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel
02/05/2020 Request to Fix Error in Docketing Regarding a Non-Existent “Closing Statement Filing” (Original Filed 02/06/2020) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
02/06/2020 “Motion for Extension of Time [until 02/14/2020] to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s 1/23 Application for Expenses (Motion #15)” Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Cavanaugh, Christopher Matthew Case Motion #17
02/10/2020 [ORIGINAL FILING] “Motion for Extension of Time [until 02/14/2020] to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s 1/23 Application for Expenses (Motion #15)” (linked to motion #17) Case Motion #17: “Motion for Extension of Time [until 02/14/2020] to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s 1/23 Application for Expenses (Motion #15)”
02/10/2020 Plaintiff’s Non-Opposition to Defendant Cavanaugh’s Request for Extension of Time to Respond to Plaintiff’s Filing of Application for Expenses Case Motion #17: “Motion for Extension of Time [until 02/14/2020] to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s 1/23 Application for Expenses (Motion #15)”
02/11/2020 Order Granting Motion Case Motion #17 “Motion for Extension of Time [until 02/14/2020] to Respond in Opposition to Plaintiff’s 1/23 Application for Expenses (Motion #15)”
02/14/2020 Motion for a Hearing Regarding Plaintiff’s Current and Previous Requests for Sanctions Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Filing Party: Cavanaugh, Christopher Matthew Case Motion #18
02/14/2020 Opposition to Case Motion #15 Case Motion #15: Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
02/19/2020 Opposition to Case Motion #15, and Request for Hearing Case Motion #15: Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
02/19/2020 [“ORIGINAL”] Motion for a Hearing Regarding Plaintiff’s Current and Previous Requests for Sanctions (linked to motion #18) Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #18: Motion for a Hearing Regarding Plaintiff’s Current and Previous Requests for Sanctions
02/19/2020 Request for Hearing Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Cavanaugh, Christopher Matthew Case Motion #19
02/19/2020 Order Granting Motion Case Motion #16 Notice of Plaintiff’s Lodging of Documents Correcting Name of Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh
02/21/2020 Certificate of Service (RE: Plaintiff’s Notice of Lodging of Documents Correcting Name of Defendant Christopher Cavanaugh, and Copies of Three Corrected Documents) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
02/25/2020 Plaintiff’s Reply Supporting Case Motion #18: Motion for a Hearing Regarding Plaintiff’s Current and Previous Requests for Sanctions
02/25/2020 Plaintiff’s Memorandum Opposing Defendant Cavanaugh’s Request for Hearing (linked to motion #19) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #19: Request for Hearing
02/25/2020 Plaintiff’s Reply Supporting Case Motion #15: Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel
02/27/2020 Order Regarding Case Motion #15 Case Motion #15: Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel
03/02/2020 Calendaring Notice issued: Motion Hearing on April 9, 2020 at 2:30 pm before Judge Crosby, courtroom 304.
04/02/2020 Calendaring Notice issued: Pursuant to Order No. 1957, Special Order No. 1831 from the Chief Justice of the Alaska Supreme Court regarding COVID-19, the Motion Hearing currently scheduled on April 9, 2020 at 2:30 pm is cancelled. Until there is clarity when hearings can be scheduled once more, the court will work with parties to reschedule.
04/20/2020 Order Regarding Pending Motions Case Motion #15: Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel, Case Motion #18: Motion for a Hearing Regarding Plaintiff’s Current and Previous Requests for Sanctions, Case Motion #19: Request for Hearing
05/05/2020 Plaintiff’s Preliminary Witness List Filed By: Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
05/06/2020 Plaintiff’s Preliminary Witness List Filed By: Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
05/06/2020 Preliminary Witness List Filed By: Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant);
05/08/2020 Plaintiff’s Response to Court’s Order Regarding Pending Motions (Original Filed 05/11/2020) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #15: Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel
05/14/2020 Request for a Rescheduling of the Hearing Regarding the Reasonableness of Sanctions in Connection with the Order Regarding Pending Motions Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Cavanaugh, Christopher Matthew Case Motion #20
05/28/2020 Order Granting Motion Case Motion #20 Request for a Rescheduling of the Hearing Regarding the Reasonableness of Sanctions in Connection with the Order Regarding Pending Motions
06/22/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #21
07/10/2020 Order - regarding over length brief Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment
07/13/2020 Motion for Order Extending Lay Witness Depositions Deadline Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V Case Motion #22
07/15/2020 Plaintiff’s Non-Opposition to Defendants’ Motion to Extend Lay Witness Deposition Deadline (linked to motion #22) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #22: Motion for Order Extending Lay Witness Depositions Deadline
07/15/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum to Accept Overlength Summary Judgment Brief, and for Consideration of Alternative Relief Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #23
07/19/2020 Order Granting Motion Case Motion #22 Motion for Order Extending Lay Witness Depositions Deadline
07/23/2020 Notice to Court Re Plaintiff’s Failure to File Motion to Accept Over-Length Brief Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant)
07/24/2020 Order Granting Leave to File Overlength Brief Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, Case Motion #23: Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum to Accept Overlength Summary Judgment Brief, and for Consideration of Alternative Relief
07/24/2020 Plaintiff’s Response to Defendant Pugh’s Factual ERror Regarding Alleged Failure to File Motion to Accept Over-Length Brief Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
07/27/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Leave of Court to Add affidavit to Exhibit 38 to Memorandum in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #24
07/31/2020 Calendaring Notice issued: Motion Hearing on August 6, 2020 at 3:30 pm - 4:30 pm before Judge Crosby, courtroom 304. Parties to be telephonic.
08/10/2020 Motion for Extension of Time [Until 08/17/2020] Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); ; Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant) Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D Case Motion #25
08/11/2020 Plaintiff’s Non-Opposition to Pugh Defendants’ Motion for Extension of Time Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); ; Thomas E Meacham (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff) Case Motion #25: Motion for Extension of Time [Until 08/17/2020]
08/11/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); ; Thomas E Meacham (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff) Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #26
08/13/2020 Notice to Court Concerning Change of Name From “Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh” to “Mattanaw” Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
08/13/2020 Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, Due to Missed Deadline, and Motion for Extension to August 17th, 2020, in Keeping With the Deadline Already Set for Defendant Pugh Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #26: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh
08/13/2020 Motion for Extension of Time to August 17th, 2020, in Keeping with the Deadline Already SEt for Defendant Pugh Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Filing Party: Mattanaw, Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Case Motion #27
08/14/2020 Order Granting Motion: Pugh Jr, Franklin D Case Motion #25–Motion for Extension of Time [Until 08/17/2020]
08/14/2020 Plaintiff’s Opposition to Defendant “Mattanaw’s” “Motion Requesting an Order to Compel Plaintiff to Respond to Discovery Request Regarding the Determination of Mr. Meacham’s Correct Rates” Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
08/14/2020 Defendant Matanaw’s Motion Requesting an Order to Compel Plaintiff to Respond to Discovery Requset Regarding the Determination of Mr. Meacham’s Correct Rates Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Filing Party: Mattanaw, Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Case Motion #28
08/17/2020 Defendant Mattanaw’s Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Mattanaw (Defendant); Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment
08/18/2020 Calendaring Notice issued: Trial Call on June 21, 2021 at 3:00 pm before Judge Crosby, courtroom 304. Parties to be telephonic.
08/18/2020 Calendaring Notice issued: Jury Trial (#2 Position) on July 19 - August 3, 2021 at 8:30 am - 1:30 pm before Judge Crosby, courtroom 304.
08/18/2020 Amended Routine Pretrial Order Issued
08/18/2020 Plaintiff’s Response Regarding Applicable Attorney Fee Rates in Discovery Sanctions Matters Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #15: Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel
08/20/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendants Franklin D. Pugh, Jr. and Oksana V. Pugh Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #29
08/20/2020 Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment—–LODGED Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Case Motion #26: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh, Case Motion #29: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendants Franklin D. Pugh, Jr. and Oksana V. Pugh
08/20/2020 Motion to Accept Late Filing of Over-Length Brief Three Days Late Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V Case Motion #30
08/24/2020

Order Granting Motion in Part

  Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc
Case Motion #15 Plaintiff’s Application for Reasonable Expenses Incurred in Preparing and Supporting Motion to Compel
08/25/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion for Extension of Time to Reply to Defendants’ Summary Judgment Opposition [18 Days or Through September 21, 2020] Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #32
08/26/2020 Plaintiff’s Request for Clarification of Court’s Order of August 24, 2020 Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #31
08/31/2020 Order Granting Plaintiff’s Motion for Extension of Time to Reply to Defendant’s Summary Judgment Oppositions Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, Case Motion #26: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh, Case Motion #29: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendants Franklin D. Pugh, Jr. and Oksana V. Pugh, Case Motion #32: Plaintiff’s Motion for Extension of Time to Reply to Defendants’ Summary Judgment Opposition [18 Days or Through September 21, 2020]
09/02/2020 Notice of Filing Supplemental Exhibits to Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085)
09/03/2020 Order Granting Motion Case Motion #30 Motion to Accept Late Filing of Over-Length Brief Three Days Late
09/03/2020 Order Granting Motion Case Motion #24 Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Leave of Court to Add affidavit to Exhibit 38 to Memorandum in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
09/03/2020 Order Granting Motion for Extension to Respond for August 17. 2020, Matching the Extension Already Expected for Defendant Pugh Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, Case Motion #26: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh, Case Motion #27: Motion for Extension of Time to August 17th, 2020, in Keeping with the Deadline Already SEt for Defendant Pugh
09/03/2020 Motion Deemed Moot Case Motion #28 Defendant Matanaw’s Motion Requesting an Order to Compel Plaintiff to Respond to Discovery Requset Regarding the Determination of Mr. Meacham’s Correct Rates
09/16/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Second Extension of Time to Reply to Defendants’ Summary Judgment Oppositions Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V; Cavanaugh, Kimberly Case Motion #33
09/16/2020 Order Granting Motion Case Motion #31 Plaintiff’s Request for Clarification of Court’s Order of August 24, 2020
09/24/2020 Order Granting Plaintiff’s Motion for Second Extension of Time to Reply to Defendant’s Summary Judgment Oppositions Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, Case Motion #26: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh, Case Motion #29: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendants Franklin D. Pugh, Jr. and Oksana V. Pugh, Case Motion #33: Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Second Extension of Time to Reply to Defendants’ Summary Judgment Oppositions
10/06/2020 Plaintiff’s Reply to Defendant Cavaugh’s Opposition to Summary Judgment Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); ; Thomas E Meacham (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff) Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, Case Motion #26: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh, Case Motion #29: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendants Franklin D. Pugh, Jr. and Oksana V. Pugh
10/06/2020 Request for Oral Argument on Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); ; Thomas E Meacham (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff) Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, Case Motion #26: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh, Case Motion #29: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendants Franklin D. Pugh, Jr. and Oksana V. Pugh
10/13/2020 Order Regarding Motion Nos. 21, 26, & 29 Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, Case Motion #26: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendant Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh, Case Motion #29: Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Summary Judgment to Plaintiff and Against Defendants Franklin D. Pugh, Jr. and Oksana V. Pugh
10/13/2020 Calendaring Notice issued: telephonic Oral Argument on November 5, 2020 at 3:00 pm - 4:00 pm before Judge Crosby.
10/22/2020 Motion for Rule of Law Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V Case Motion #34
10/29/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum to Vacate Date of Oral Argument on Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, and to Reschedule Oral Argument Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #35
10/30/2020 Defendants Pughs’ Response to Plaintiff’s Motion to Vacate Date of Oral Argument Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Case Motion #35: Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum to Vacate Date of Oral Argument on Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, and to Reschedule Oral Argument
11/02/2020 Reply in Support of Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum to Vacate Date of Oral Argument and to Re-Schedule Oral Argument Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Case Motion #35: Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum to Vacate Date of Oral Argument on Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, and to Reschedule Oral Argument
11/03/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Extension of Time to Oppose Defendant Pugh’s Motion for Rule of Law [through November 17, 2020] Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #36
11/03/2020 Calendaring Notice issued: Oral Argument on November 5, 2020 has been vacated per 11/3/2020 order. This telephonic hearing has been rescheduled to December 10, 2020 at 3:00 pm - 4:00 pm before Judge Crosby. Regarding motions ##21 and 34.
11/03/2020 Plaintiff’s Response to Court’s Notice and Order Granting Case Motion No.35 (linked to motions #21 & #35) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, Case Motion #35: Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum to Vacate Date of Oral Argument on Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, and to Reschedule Oral Argument
11/03/2020 Plaintiff’s Reply to Defendant Pugh’s Opposition to Summary Judgment (linked to motion #21) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment
11/03/2020 Plaintiff’s Reply to Defendant Cavanaugh’s Opposition to Summary Judgment (linked to motion #21) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment
11/03/2020

Order Granting Motion

  Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc
Case Motion #35 Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum to Vacate Date of Oral Argument on Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, and to Reschedule Oral Argument
11/04/2020 Motion for Reduction of Court Awarded Attorney’s Fees for Case Motion #15 by that Amount Overpaid for Case Motion #9 Due to Plaintiff’s Inflated Rates Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Mattanaw (Defendant);
11/04/2020 Defendant Mattanaw’s Non-Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion to Re-schedule Oral Arguments (linked to motion #35) Self-Represented (0100001) Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Mattanaw, Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #35: Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum to Vacate Date of Oral Argument on Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, and to Reschedule Oral Argument
11/10/2020 Plaintiff’s Non-Opposition to Relief Requested in Defendant Mattanaw’s Motion to Deduct Amount from Discovery Sanction (linked to motion #37) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #37: Motion for Reduction of Court Awarded Attorney’s Fees for Case Motion #15 by that Amount Overpaid for Case Motion #9 Due to Plaintiff’s Inflated Rates
11/13/2020 Order Granting Motion Mattanaw, Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Case Motion #37 Motion for Reduction of Court Awarded Attorney’s Fees for Case Motion #15 by that Amount Overpaid for Case Motion #9 Due to Plaintiff’s Inflated Rates
11/16/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Grant of Second Extension of Time to Oppose Defendant Pugh’s Motion for Rule of Law [until November 20, 2020] Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #38
11/16/2020 Defendants Pughs’ Non-Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Grant of Second Extension of Time to Oppose Defendant Pugh’s Motion for Rule of Law Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Case Motion #38: Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Grant of Second Extension of Time to Oppose Defendant Pugh’s Motion for Rule of Law [until November 20, 2020]
11/18/2020 Order: Granting Plaintiff’s Motion for Second Extension of Time to Oppose Defendant Pugh’s Motion for Rule of Law Case Motion #34: Motion for Rule of Law, Case Motion #38: Plaintiff’s Motion and Memorandum for Grant of Second Extension of Time to Oppose Defendant Pugh’s Motion for Rule of Law [until November 20, 2020]
11/18/2020 Motion Deemed Moot Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #36 Plaintiff’s Motion for Grant of Extension of Time to Oppose Defendant Pugh’s Motion for Rule of Law [through November 17, 2020]
11/23/2020 Plaintiff’s Opposition to Motion for Rule of Law (linked to motion #34) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #34: Motion for Rule of Law
11/23/2020 Cross-Motion for Rule of Law Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #39
12/03/2020 Defendants Pughs’ Reply to Opposition to Motion for Rule of Law and Opposition to Plaintiff’s Cross-Motion for Rule of Law Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Case Motion #39: Cross-Motion for Rule of Law
12/03/2020 Defendants Pughs’ Reply to Opposition to Motion for Rule of Law [filed on same pleading as Opposition to Plaintiff’s Cross-Motion for Rule of Law] (linked to motion #34) Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Case Motion #34: Motion for Rule of Law
12/07/2020 Plaintiff’s Correction of Exhibit Compilation Omission: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 38-46 (Affidavit of Thomas C. Pease) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment
12/10/2020 Plaintiff’s Reply in Support of Cross-Motion on Rule of Law (linked to motion #39) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #39: Cross-Motion for Rule of Law
12/11/2020 Second Amended Routine Pretrial Order Issued
12/30/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion for Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #40
12/30/2020 Notice of Deficient Filing(s) mailed re: The Motion for Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status and Supporting Memorandum filed 12/30/2020 are lacking a complete signature. Please amend your documents and resubmit to the court Notice of Deficient Filing (Anchorage) (10/18) Sent on: 12/30/2020 13:34:58.81 Thomas E Meacham (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
12/30/2020 Plaintiff’s Motion for Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status Thomas E Meacham (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff) Case Motion #40: Plaintiff’s Motion for Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status
12/31/2020

[CURED] Civil Deficiency Memo mailed re: The Plaintiff’s Motion for Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status, filed 12/30/2020, lacks the proposed order.

Civil Deficiency Memo (8/18) Sent on: 12/31/2020 07:55:32.29
12/31/2020 [Proposed] Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status Thomas E Meacham (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff) Case Motion #40: Plaintiff’s Motion for Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status
01/22/2021 Partial Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Case Motion #40: Plaintiff’s Motion for Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status
01/26/2021 Plaintiff’s Motion for Extension of Time to Reply to Defendant Pugh’s Response to Jury Trial Motion [until 02/08/2021] Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #41
01/27/2021 CD/Tape Duplication Receipt: 1818305 Date: 02/01/2021
01/27/2021 Copies Made per Admin Rule 9 (e)(1) For a single document or portion of a document $5 If copies of multiple documents are requested at the same time, for each additional document (after the first) $3 Receipt: 1818305 Date: 02/01/2021
02/04/2021 Order Regarding Motion Nos. 34 & 39 Case Motion #34: Motion for Rule of Law, Case Motion #39: Cross-Motion for Rule of Law
02/08/2021 Plaintiff’s Reply Regarding Jury Trial Issue Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Case Motion #40: Plaintiff’s Motion for Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status
02/12/2021 Order Granting Plaintiff’s Motion for Extension of Time to Reply to Defendant Pugh’s Response to Jury Trial Motion Case Motion #40: Plaintiff’s Motion for Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status, Case Motion #41: Plaintiff’s Motion for Extension of Time to Reply to Defendant Pugh’s Response to Jury Trial Motion [until 02/08/2021]
02/12/2021 Order Granting Motion Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #40 Plaintiff’s Motion for Order Determining Non-Jury Trial Status
06/06/2021 Order Denying Motion Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #21 Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment
06/17/2021 Plaintiff’s Counsel’s Notice of Absence From The State of Alaska (From June 16, 2021 Through June 29, 2021) Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
06/17/2021 Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule 60(a) Relief Due to Clerical Mistakes or Errors Arising from Oversight or Omission Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #42
06/23/2021 Notice and Order Case Motion #42: Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule 60(a) Relief Due to Clerical Mistakes or Errors Arising from Oversight or Omission
06/29/2021 Response and Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule 60(a) Felief Due to Clerical Mistakes or Errors Arising From Oversight or Omission Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Oksana V Pugh (Defendant) Case Motion #42: Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule 60(a) Relief Due to Clerical Mistakes or Errors Arising from Oversight or Omission
06/30/2021 Notice of Errata Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant) Case Motion #42: Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule 60(a) Relief Due to Clerical Mistakes or Errors Arising from Oversight or Omission
07/07/2021 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Reply Regarding Plaintiff’s Rule 60(a) Motion [until July 16, 2021] Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #43
07/09/2021 Order Granting Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Reply Regarding Plaintiff’s Rule 60(a) Motion Case Motion #42: Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule 60(a) Relief Due to Clerical Mistakes or Errors Arising from Oversight or Omission, Case Motion #43: Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Reply Regarding Plaintiff’s Rule 60(a) Motion [until July 16, 2021]
07/19/2021 Plaintiff’s Reply to Pugh Defendants’ Response and Opposition to Plaintiff’s Rule 60(a) Motion Thomas E Meacham (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff) Case Motion #42: Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule 60(a) Relief Due to Clerical Mistakes or Errors Arising from Oversight or Omission
08/17/2021 Order Regarding Motion No. 42 Case Motion #42: Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule 60(a) Relief Due to Clerical Mistakes or Errors Arising from Oversight or Omission
08/17/2021 Order Granting Motion in Part Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #42 Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule 60(a) Relief Due to Clerical Mistakes or Errors Arising from Oversight or Omission
08/17/2021 Amended Order Denying Motion No. 21 Case Motion #21: Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment
08/17/2021 Plaintiff’s Preliminary Witness List Attorney: Meacham, Thomas E (7111032) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
08/24/2021 Defendants Franklin D Pugh Jr. and Oksana V Pugh’s Expert Witness List Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant)
08/24/2021 Defendants Frankin D Pugh Jr. and Oksana V Pugh’s Preliminary Witness List Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant)
09/21/2021 Motion for Extension of Time [until October 1, 2021] Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V Case Motion #44
09/30/2021 Defendants Franklin D. Pugh, Jr. and Oksana V. Pugh’s Other Expert Opinion Testimony Summary Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant);
10/04/2021 Entry of Appearance Attorney Gross, David K representing Plaintiff Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc as of 10/04/2021 Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
10/04/2021 Attorney Information Attorney Falsey, William D representing Plaintiff Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc as of 10/04/2021
10/07/2021 Order Granting Motion Pugh Jr, Franklin D Case Motion #44 Motion for Extension of Time [until October 1, 2021]
10/26/2021 Stipulation to Modify Pre-Trial Deadline Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V Case Motion #45
10/28/2021 Order Granting Motion Pugh Jr, Franklin D Case Motion #45 Stipulation to Modify Pre-Trial Deadline
11/04/2021 Stipulation to Modify Pre-Trial Deadline Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V Case Motion #46
11/05/2021 Order Granting Motion Pugh Jr, Franklin D Case Motion #46 Stipulation to Modify Pre-Trial Deadline
11/17/2021 Motion to Accept Filing of Over-Length Brief Two Days Late Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V Case Motion #47
11/17/2021 Motion for Summary Judgment Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V Case Motion #48
12/02/2021 Order Granting Motion Pugh Jr, Franklin D Case Motion #47 Motion to Accept Filing of Over-Length Brief Two Days Late
12/02/2021 LODGED—–Friends’ Opposition to Pughs’ Motion for Summary Judgment Attorney: Falsey, William D (0511099) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff); Case Motion #48: Motion for Summary Judgment
12/02/2021 Motion to Accept Overlength Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment Attorney: Gross, David K (9611065) Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #49
12/07/2021 Plaintiff’s Deposition Designations Attorney: Gross, David K (9611065) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
12/09/2021 Motion for Extension of Pretrial Deadlines Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V Case Motion #50
12/10/2021 Motion for Extension of Time [until December 17, 2021 to reply] Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V Case Motion #51
12/13/2021 Order Granting Motion on Record Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #49 Motion to Accept Overlength Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
12/13/2021 Order Granting Motion on Record Pugh Jr, Franklin D Case Motion #50 Motion for Extension of Pretrial Deadlines
12/13/2021 Order Granting Motion on Record Pugh Jr, Franklin D Case Motion #51 Motion for Extension of Time [until December 17, 2021 to reply]
12/14/2021 Calendaring Notice issued.
12/20/2021 “Agreement Granting Permission to Hike Across Property” Exhibit N Case Motion #48: Motion for Summary Judgment
12/20/2021 Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr, Oksana V Pugh (Defendant) Case Motion #48: Motion for Summary Judgment
12/21/2021 Defendants’ Deposition Designations Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant);
12/28/2021 Plaintiff’s Objections and Counter-Designations Attorney: Gross, David K (9611065) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
12/29/2021 Plaintiff’s Supplemental Deposition Designation Attorney: Gross, David K (9611065) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
12/29/2021 Defendants’ Deposition Objections and Counter-Designations Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant);
01/04/2022 Defendant’s Objections to Defendants’ Counter-Designations David K Gross (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
01/04/2022 Plaintiff’s Trial Brief David K Gross (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
01/04/2022 Plaintiff’s Final Witness List David K Gross (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
01/04/2022 Plaintiff’s Objections to Defendants’ Exhibits David K Gross (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
01/05/2022 Defendants Franklin D Pugh Jr and Oksana V Pugh’s Trial Brief Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant)
01/05/2022 Defendants’ Objections to Plantiff’s Trial Exhibits Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant)
01/10/2022 Plaintiff’s Supplemental Deposition Designation David K Gross (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
01/10/2022 Defendants Franklin D Pugh Jr and Oksana V Pugh’s Final Witness List Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant)
01/11/2022 Defendants Franklin D Pugh Jr and Oksana V Pugh’s Status Report Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant)
01/11/2022 [Proposed] Order Regarding Plaintiff’s Assertion of Attorney - Client Privilege (Creates Motion Record) Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant); Filing Party: Pugh Jr, Franklin D; Pugh, Oksana V Case Motion #52
01/11/2022 Order Denying Motion #48 Pugh Jr, Franklin D Case Motion #48 Motion for Summary Judgment
01/12/2022 Plaintiff’s Objections to Defendants Supplemental Exhibits David K Gross (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
01/12/2022 Response to Status Report David K Gross (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
01/12/2022 Plaintiff’s Amended Final Witness List David K Gross (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
01/13/2022 Notice to the Court Regarding Covid David K Gross (Attorney) on behalf of Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff)
01/16/2022 Order Regarding Privilege Log
01/16/2022 Order Denying Motion Pugh Jr, Franklin D Case Motion #52 [Proposed] Order Regarding Plaintiff’s Assertion of Attorney - Client Privilege (Creates Motion Record)
01/18/2022 Notice Concerning Desire to Postpone if There are Covid Related Concerns and Unusual Trials Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Mattanaw (Defendant);
01/18/2022 Defendant’s Mattanaw’s Final Witness List Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Mattanaw (Defendant);
01/18/2022 Defendant Mattanaw’s Trial Brief Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Mattanaw (Defendant);
01/18/2022 First Affidavit of Mattanaw Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Mattanaw (Defendant);
01/18/2022 Defendants’ Supplemental Deposition Designations and Counter-Designations Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant)
01/18/2022 Defendants’ Supplemental Deposition Designations Kevin T Fitzgerald (Attorney) on behalf of Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant)
01/24/2022 Plaintiff’s Objections to Defendant Mattanaw’s Exhibits Attorney: Gross, David K (9611065) Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc (Plaintiff);
01/24/2022 Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule of Law (Admissibility of Affidavit Testimony) Attorney: Gross, David K (9611065) Filing Party: Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #53
01/25/2022 CD/Tape Duplication Receipt: 1934634 Date: 01/25/2022
01/26/2022 “Second Amended Evidence List” Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Mattanaw (Defendant);
01/31/2022 CD/Tape Duplication Receipt: 1936047 Date: 01/31/2022
01/31/2022 CD/Tape Duplication Receipt: 1936047 Date: 01/31/2022
01/31/2022 Order Regarding Deposition Designations
01/31/2022 Motion for Mistrial Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Mattanaw (Defendant); Filing Party: Mattanaw, Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Case Motion #54
01/31/2022 Exhibit List for Defendants (Exhibit I.D. 2001 - 2064) Attorney: Fitzgerald, Kevin T (8711085) Franklin D Pugh Jr (Defendant); Oksana V Pugh (Defendant);
02/01/2022 Order Regarding Motion #53 Case Motion #53: Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule of Law (Admissibility of Affidavit Testimony)
02/01/2022 CD/Tape Duplication Receipt: 1936496 Date: 02/01/2022
02/01/2022 Order Denying Motion Friends Of The Stewart Public Trail Inc Case Motion #53 Plaintiff’s Motion for Rule of Law (Admissibility of Affidavit Testimony)
02/02/2022 Order Regarding Motion #54 Case Motion #54: Motion for Mistrial
02/02/2022 Amended Motion for Mistrial (linked to motion #54) Self-Represented (0100001) Mattanaw Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh Mattanaw, Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant); Case Motion #54: Motion for Mistrial
02/03/2022 Notice Rescheduling Hearing issued.
02/14/2022 Calendaring Notice issued
02/17/2022 Notice Rescheduling Hearing issued
03/02/2022 Plaintiff’s and defendant’s admitted exhibits are stored in courtroom 304 pending final decision/appeal time - R.U.
03/02/2022 Hearing Findings Taken Under Advisement Judge Crosby, Danya (9809041) Case Motion #55
03/14/2022 Notice
01/01/2999 Consent to Service by Fax or E-mail Between Parties [Filed 07-16-2019] Christopher Matthew Cavanaugh (Defendant);
01/01/2999 See Judge Gandbhir’s 8/28/19 Order in Volume 2 case file RE: Faxed pleadings by Christopher Cavanaugh Any Faxed Pleadings Must State That an Original Is Being Filed Contemporaneously With The Court

Docket Disposition

Perempt Disqual by Defendant/Respondent/Appellee 05/01/2019 Miller, Gregory A
Recusal by Judge 11/05/2019 Gandbhir, Una
Undisposed Crosby, Dani R

Post Trial Civil Issues

Recordings